Martial Arts vs Combat Sports

I tend to use the terms “Martial Arts” and “Combat Sports” interchangeably because in my mind, they are. I realize there are purists out there who get weirdly pedantic about that. “Wrestling and Boxing aren’t martial arts.” Yes, they are. I don’t care, dude. They are. Generally it seems like this distinction is important to guys who are into “traditional” martial arts, such as Karate, Kung Fu or Tae Kwon Do. I put the word “traditional” in quotes because I think that term in this context is also ridiculous, but I’ll expand upon that a few paragraphs down. My main point here is that in each fighting style, there is a sport component and an artistic component. For purposes of this discussion, “sport” refers to the physical and competitive aspects; balance, strength, conditioning, cardio, flexibility, speed, etc. and “art” refers to the mental and internal aspects; strategy, timing, technique, creativity and emotional control.

I don’t what the fuck is happening in this picture but it looked cool so I used it. And that’s what makes me a pro. 😀

I acknowledge that Boxing and Wrestling are most definitely combat sports. This is not in dispute. There is most definitely an art to them, however. And they are martial in nature. On the flip side, what people refer to as “traditional” martial arts have a sport element to them, and the sport aspect is most definitely combat related. The way some have explained the distinction is like this: a combat sport focuses on athleticism and competition whereas a martial art focuses on kata, meditation, and the tradition and history of the art. Okay. Interesting. I would contend that for combat sports, the equivalent of kata could be the movements they drill repeatedly eg footwork, shots, sprawls, jabs, crosses, hooks, uppercuts… just like kata in Karate but more specific to what that athlete/artist will be doing in that specific discipline. The meditation part of Karate or Kung Fu for example is equivalent to the mental preparation that a wrestler or boxer puts into their discipline. What really is the significant difference?

A quick aside, regarding the term “traditional” in this context, I find it funny that Karate, Kung Fu, Aikido, Tae Kwon Do, Judo, etc are considered “traditional” whereas Boxing and Wrestling are not. Look, for fuck sake, Wrestling and Boxing are older than any of those disciplines. They are the oldest disciplines out there, how are they not steeped in history or tradition? This is also why the term “traditional” in reference to other martial arts is silly. They all have long and storied traditions, even a comparatively new art like Brazilian Jiu Jitsu has deep traditions. They are all “traditional” in nature.

So when I talk about the topic of martial arts, to be clear, I am talking about all fighting styles; Boxing. Wrestling, whether it’s Greco Roman, Freestyle, or Folk, or Pankration, which is basically Submission Wrestling but with kicks and slaps. Karate in its many styles. Kung Fu, also in its many styles. Tae Kwon Do. Judo. Brazilian Jiu Jitsu. Vale Tudo. Japanese Jiu Jitsu. Russian Sambo. Muay Thai. Muay Boran. Savate. Lethwei. Pencak Silat. Jeet Kune Do. Tang Soo Do. Dambe. Fencing. Escrima. Senegalese Wrestling. Mongolian Spatula Fighting. Antarctican Snowshoe Boxing. Martian Bacteria Flagellum Wrestling. Whatever. It’s all good.

It’s up to us as individual martial artists to find our own balance between art and sport. The sport aspect keeps you healthy, strong and durable. The art aspect keeps your mind sharp and your techniques on point. Drilling your technique over and over gives you a chance to find your rhythm and get into the proverbial “zone.” It helps unite body and mind, programming muscle memory to fire the technique automatically, and learning to see and anticipate multiple scenarios from that position. Sparring, or rolling, also unites body and mind, teaching us to stay calm and focused under pressure. There is a Zen to both drilling and sparring. 

If you focus mostly on the sport aspect of your fighting style, you are most likely capable of effective hand to hand self defense in a street fight. But I would implore you to focus on the artistic aspect of it whether it’s boxing, wrestling, Judo, Jiu Jitsu, Karate, Muay Thai, whatever… If you’re athletic and get by mostly on having greater strength or speed, take a moment to slow down. Focus on technique, and staying calm. Roll with less strength or speed, and see if you can still execute the moves. Treat your drilling like a meditation. Showing up at the gym and taking the class should be as much mental and spiritual development as it is a physical workout.

Conversely, if you attend a school or study a style that focuses mainly on the art, but little on the sport, then how do you know your training is at all effective in a combat situation? It may be worth your while to visit a gym that focuses on sparring and see if you can try a few classes there. How does your Karate hold up when you go and spar at the local kickboxing gym? How does your Aikido hold up when you try a few trial classes at the local BJJ academy? A little live sparring against fit, calculating, skilled humans can be a real eye opener. And, your mind will be sharper and clearer in a high stress scenario if you spar, because you will be used to getting hit. You will be used to having an opponent try to take you down and strangle you. 

So, in summation, athletes need the art, and artists need the sport. Engaging both the art and sport aspects of your discipline is a must for becoming a more complete fighter. And making the distinction between “Martial Art” and “Combat Sport” is, these days, trivial and petty (although I realize the irony of me holding that view point yet writing an article this long on the topic). Enjoy your martial arts journey, and remember to breathe. Happy training.

4 thoughts on “Martial Arts vs Combat Sports

  1. You have a new follower!
    I really enjoy this article. I’m particularly interested in exploring spatula fighting!
    I recently saw a Krav Maga YouTube video and in the description it says that “Krav Maga is not a martial art.” Then, the description goes on to say how KM was developed by the Israeli Defense Force… smh… you just described a **martial** art!
    I also like the fact that you put quotes around “traditional” martial arts. Some people still own cars older than even the oldest organized “traditional” karate style.
    Your advice about martial artists (in whatever their particular flavor) getting out of their comfort zones and also learning something different from someone who studies a different fighting method is quite refreshing. For example, I *hate* grappling with wrestlers… not because they don’t have anything of value to offer. It is precisely the opposite. They are the ones most likely to humble me the quickest! Their speed, power, innate understanding of body weight and pressure is absolutely incredible… and frustrating! So, if I want to roll in a BJJ gym, I’ll seek out guys with a wrestling background because they are the ones that are going to be an even greater challenge than the other skilled players on the mat.
    I built a blog site for my sensei’s dojo, and I’ve been posting thoughts on there as well. I would be grateful for feedback! https://scienceofthemartialarts.com/

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thanks man, I appreciate the kind words. Spatula fighting can be very dangerous, it’s good to start with a soft training spatula before moving up the ranks. 😀 You bring up a good point about rolling with people who will challenge you, force you out of your comfort zone, and make you uncomfortable. In any given class, I make it a point to roll with a) someone who is better than me b) someone I can beat and c) someone on the same level as me, albeit with a size difference. You’ll learn something from each. The person who beats you shows you the holes in you game and reminds you to be humble. The person you can beat allows you to perfect your moves and gain confidence. Anyone in between will also impart a valuable lesson. Happy training my friend. Also, I’ve neglected this blog due to being super busy but you’ve inspired me to get back to posting. I hope to post an article about wristlocks soon. I’ll check out your blog. Have a good one.

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: